Rating Ron Gourlay’s Signings At Reading FC: Is It Time For Him To Quit The Royals?

The Madejski Stadium is not a nice place to be at the moment, and the international break could not come soon enough for the Royals. But what is causing all these issues for Reading FC? Is it Paul Clement? Is it the owners? Nope, it is Ron Gourlay and his recruitment. Is it any coincidence that since he’s moved to RG2, the Royals’ form has taken a catastrophic turn? Not at all.

Since he arrived in July 2017, Gourlay helped sign 13 players, only two of who have been a success (so far). One benefit of Gourlay’s recruitment is the fact that there are a higher number of domestic signings than Reading were previously making, with only one of the 13 signings being players from abroad. However, he refuses to take any blame for his errors, and publically coming out and saying “the bulk of players (he has signed since July 2017) have been a success”, shows the ignorance of the former Chelsea CEO. So which of Gourlay’s signings have been a success? We discuss this below with a rating for each player:

Jon Dadi Bodvarsson – 6/10

The Icelandic striker is a fan favourite in Berkshire. He always gives his all and has scored a decent amount of goals, but he is not the 20-goal-a-season striker we were crying out for at that time. This is one of Gourlay’s better signings, however still not good enough.

Vito Mannone – 5/10

Was nowhere near good enough to fill the void left by Ali Al-Habsi after he left for Al-Hilal in the same summer. He has made quite a lot of avoidable mistakes since arriving, and I am sure there were better options than him available in the market.

Modou Barrow – 8.5/10

By far Gourlay’s best signing. He is creative, attack-minded and a great finisher. He was precisely what the Royals needed, but it was just unfortunate that he was playing in such a poor side. He will be key this season in keeping Reading in the Championship.

Leandro Bacuna – 5/10

Underwhelming. Very underwhelming. He hasn’t been atrocious, but just nowhere near the quality, we needed in that position. Royals fans were hoping for someone to replace Danny Williams, but Bacuna does not have the work rate to do the same job, and it just seemed like a completely pointless signing.

David Edwards – 1/10

 I am not even going to comment on this one. 

Sone Aluko – 4/10

He has flattered to deceive since his arrival last summer. He has never shown any consistency and hasn’t justified the price tag Reading splashed to bring him to RG2 from Fulham.

It is very early to give a definitive rating for this summers signings, but I will do it on what we have seen so far.

Andy Yiadom – 9/10

Faultless so far. Best right-back we’ve had for years.

David Meyler – 5/10

Very average. He is very slow off the mark, and it often costs us.

John O’Shea – 5/10

The only game he played was against a good Watford side so would be harsh to judge.

Marc McNulty – 6/10

Looks very sharp, needs a goal soon to get him going.

Darren Sidoel – N/A

Under-23’s signing, can’t say I have seen him play but sounds like he is playing quite well.

Sam Walker – 6/10

Made some good saves in the games he has played. Needs to be patient and wait for his chance in the league.

Sam Baldock – 6/10

Works hard, but hasn’t been clinical in front of goal as of yet. Could be a good player for us this season.

Some of the recruitment from Gourlay has been awful, and I am not sure any Royals fans would be disappointed if he left the club.

The following two tabs change content below.

Tom Amies

Tom is passionate about football and is looking for a career in sports journalism. He’s a Reading fan and season ticket holder and will be providing as much Royals content as he can.

Share This Article

Liverpool Set To Miss Out On 21 Y/O Forward Who Favours Move To Chelsea: Double Blow For The Reds?

Next Story »

The UEFA Nations League And What It Means For The Home Nations


  • Scout Report Of How Joe Gelhardt Would Be A Better Fit In Liverpool Attack If Brought As Duncan’s Successor

    2 weeks ago

    Bobby Duncan must have overcome his mental stress now upon completion of the desired transfer to Fiorentina. Liverpool sanctioned the transfer on the European deadline day even ...

    Read More
  • Liverpool Confirm Duncan Departure: 3 Replacements For Klopp To Consider Including Serie A Ace

    3 weeks ago

    Liverpool have confirmed the departure of Bobby Duncan on their official website after the English striker agreed to make a switch to Fiorentina this summer. The Whiston-born ...

    Read More
  • This Player Undergoes Medical At Celtic: Strengths And Weaknesses Of This Exciting Talent

    3 weeks ago

    According to the report from BBC, Celtic are set to seal the deal for Kilmarnock’s left-back Greg Taylor in the next 24 hours. The Scottish heavyweights had ...

    Read More
  • Borussia Dortmund Comes In For Bobby Duncan: Has The Liverpool Ace Done Irrevocable Damage To His Reputation?

    3 weeks ago

    All the tantrum and mayhem seem to have cooled down since the past couple of days, but the damage is already done by Saif Rubie who lambasted ...

    Read More
  • Has Harry Maguire Solved Manchester United’s Defensive Problems?

    1 month ago

    In a summer that saw £1.41bn spent on transfers in the Premier League, one move stood out from the rest for several reasons. Harry Maguire is a ...

    Read More